How are some songs able to remain on YouTube for years (via unofficial channels) while others are taken down almost immediately?

538 views

For example, Garth Brooks is notorious for sending out DMCA requests liberally on all unauthorized platforms, yet I can search YouTube and find all of his songs easily that have been there for years and are obviously unofficial channels. I know YouTube has an algorithm, and Garth Brooks is a pretty well known artist, so I don’t see how the algorithm could not detect and remove these. Garth himself could search and find these as easily as I could, I imagine, so how do they stay up?

In: Technology

5 Answers

Anonymous 0 Comments

YouTube has a system called ContentID. It recognizes sounds and videos that are registered into it in other uploaded content.

When a video gets flagged by the ContentID system, the original author of the content gets to control the monetization of the video. They control whether or not ads are shown on the video, and they get the revenue from those ads.

So if I uploaded a random video with Garth Brooks music to it, then Google would recognize the audio, flag it as belonging to Garth Brooks’ label, and it would be monetized with the revenue going to Garth Brooks’ label.

There isn’t much incentive to DMCA all the stuff on YouTube since YouTube has setup a system to get them the money from the content anyways.

Anonymous 0 Comments

I guess they slow the Original song down about 1% So its an alternate version. Then its legal.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Yuotube has a couple of different ways they allow people to deal with violations. One is to have the problem video removed. Another is to allow it to remain, but to demonetize it for the original uploader. That is, if there is an ad on the video, the money goes to the copyright owner (the music company, in this kind of case) and not to the person uploading the video.

Many artists only care about “piracy” in the sense that they aren’t getting paid, so if YouTube provides a method that they get paid for someone listening to their songs even if it’s just some random internet guy posting, they’re OK with it.

Anonymous 0 Comments

Not a total explanation, but it sheds some light on the subject – https://youtu.be/uHh8nPj5SDY

Anonymous 0 Comments

Try listening to some of that “Garth Brooks.” Nearly all of it is someone else singing and definitely not Garth.