ELIF how one can whistle any song they are thinking about but when it comes to playing it on a keyboard, a novice player cannot get past first few keys?

Question

ELIF how one can whistle any song they are thinking about but when it comes to playing it on a keyboard, a novice player cannot get past first few keys?

In: Biology

Answer 1

Because even if you know the melody, most non pianist cant map them to the keys easily. Once you play the wrong key your mind gets thrown off and you start over

Answer 2

I’d imagine that if a piano were part of your physical anatomy, it would be just as easy as using your vocal cords since they would be directly connected to your neural interface.

Answer 3

The same reason why you can speak anything you can think of but sitting down to write it is more challenging. Whistling is easier to practice because you just need to exist in a place where you can breathe to do it, whereas practicing an instrument requires more.